only search counterfire.org

No one can justify such attacks, but the shootings in France are the terrible and disastrous outcome of the West's war policies and anti-Muslim racism writes Lindsey German

SarkozyThe shootings in south west France were, it appears, the work of a young Algerian Muslim, who had been trained in camps in Afghanistan and Pakistan and was one of the prisoners who escaped from Kandahar prison in a Taliban jailbreak.

No one can justify such attacks, which have seen the killing of Jewish schoolchildren and a rabbi, and of French soldiers of North African and Caribbean descent.

But nor should anyone be in any doubt that this act cannot be explained as an isolated hate crime, or the deed of one fanatic. It is the terrible and disastrous outcome of a series of policies which could have been avoided and which now risk making the situation even worse.

Firstly there have been the years of racism against Muslims in France. The current presidential election campaign has seen incumbent Nicolas Sarkozy whip up a racist storm in an attempt to win votes from the far right National Front. He attacked those who were not French, inferred that the French were being forced to eat halal meat.

The ban on women wearing the hijab in school, the high rates of unemployment among North African descent youth, the police repression in the banlieues which surround France’s major cities, have all contributed to this wave of racism. Sarkozy now appeals for unity but he has spent recent weeks creating disunity between races.

The shooting at the Jewish school in Toulouse on Monday took place on the 50th anniversary of the end of the Algerian war for independence, a war which still has a bitter legacy of racism and colonialism in France.

The recent wars in Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya were supposed to end terrorism. Instead terrorism has grown around the world. The grievances over the wars have lengthened in the past ten years. The continued occupations of mainly Muslim countries, the inability to deal with the question of the Palestinians, the current threats to  Iran, and perhaps most importantly the growing number of deaths of civilians in Afghanistan, have all fuelled this sense of grievance.

The killing of 16 Afghan civilians at the hands of a US soldier two weeks ago was treated with much less outrage than the French killings, leading to the perception that Afghan lives are worth less than those of westerners.

Former head of MI5, Eliza Manningham Buller, in evidence at the Chilcot inquiry into the Iraq war said that intelligence services had warned the British government that these wars would exacerbate terrorism not decrease it.

Those who supported the wars are like the Bourbons - they learn nothing and forget nothing. Their response to this terrible act will be more justification for wars, more money spent on the military and weaponry, more surveillance of Muslims, more support for extensions of the war to ‘root out terrorism’.

They will also continue to treat Muslims as second class citizens, increasing restrictions on what they can wear or how they behave. Islamophobia is not some aberration in France: it stems directly from the support for imperialist wars and the legacy of colonial rule.

The way to end the terror attacks would be to find a political solution to the grievances and injustices which give rise to it in the first place. Fat chance of Sarkozy, Cameron and the rest even thinking about that.

From Stop the War site

Comments   

 
#1 RE: Toulouse murders: the policies that produced an atrocityDan 2012-03-23 14:54
So according to Ms German this is a not a hate crime because it had political motivations?
Sorry but it is a hate crime. The murder was motivated by the hatred of the people he killed. Whether he had grievances towards the policies of their government is irrelvant.
 
 
#2 RE: Toulouse murders: the policies that produced an atrocityMark 2012-03-25 16:12
I rather think Dan that Lindsey is saying it WAS a hate BECAUSE of the racist policies of the French government which have created an environment which encourages and in this case produced such racist hate crime
 

National demonstration and free festival
Assemble 1pm, BBC HQ, Portland Place
March to Parliament

Dangerous Times Festival

Local events

APR
26

Sat 26 Apr 10:30 - 13:30
Leafletting Session to Build June 21st Demonstration

APR
26

Sat 26 Apr 14:30 - 17:30
PO PO Screening + Q&A

MAY
02

Fri 2 May 19:00 - 22:00
Nottingham: We Will be Free! Tolpuddle Martyrs Story

MAY
07

Wed 7 May 19:30 - 21:30
Hackney Keep Our NHS Public meeting - Council candidates must pledge to stop sell-off of NHS

MAY
10

Sat 10 May 14:00 - 19:00
THE PEOPLE V AUSTERITY

MAY
10

Sat 10 May 14:00 - 17:00
The People V Austerity

Counterfire events

Counterfire Broadsheet